The golden ratio does not explain your photographs

0
647
Fotograma de la película Pi Fe en el Caos de Darren Aronofsky (1998)
Fotograma de la película Pi Fe en el Caos de Darren Aronofsky (1998)

After this series of articles in which I have delved into the constructs and conventions of beauty in art and, in particular, in photography, with the previous articles “Cartier-Bresson’s Hyères: when context teaches us to look” and “The rule of thirds is a lie, but AI doesn’t know it,” I continue with a new text about another recurring grid, or visual convention linked to the search for beauty as an aesthetic convention or as a construction of guaranteed value. In this case, we will discuss the classic — or not so classic — golden ratio, and how the interpretation of images based on this geometric relationship can present significant methodological weaknesses.

1. When a template replaces a theory

The golden region possesses a virtue that explains much of its cultural persistence: it allows transforming an ambiguous experience into a mathematical model capable of stabilizing that ambiguity into an objective response. Where aesthetic judgment is uncertain, historical, debatable, or even uncomfortable, this relationship offers a stable solution. Photography then ceases to be evidence of a fact and becomes the illustration that proves a number. This operation is very common in composition manuals, social media comments, retrospective analyses of famous images, and popular readings of paintings prior to modernity. A spiral fits the silhouette of a face, the diagonal of a body, the edge of a mountain, the curve of a wave, or the gesture of a figure, and the conclusion is usually presented as if the finding revealed the hidden reason for the beauty of the image.

The procedure is methodologically as fragile as it is banal: first, because it usually starts from the shape one wants to find (confirmation bias or illusion of correlation). Multiple possible geometric relationships are not compared, measurement points are not predefined, the hypothesis is not contrasted with equivalent images that are not considered valuable, and it is not determined whether the result exceeds what is expected by chance or retrospective fitting; second, because the photographic image admits numerous crops, scales, and anchor points. The same photograph can be cropped in different ways and, with sufficient flexibility, it will almost always be possible to find some segment, empty space, or focal point that seems to approximate that 1.618 ratio. Third, because the geometric proof is confused with an aesthetic explanation: that a spatial relationship is present in an image does not imply that it was intentional, nor that it explains the viewer’s experience, nor that it determines its artistic value.

The objection, therefore, is not to deny that relevant proportional relationships may exist in some images; it would be equally limited to exclude measurement from visual analysis. Photographic composition works with weights, directions, tensions, balances, asymmetries, scales, rhythms, repetitions, and discontinuities. Framing organizes the visual field, but the golden region becomes problematic when it ceases to be a heuristic tool and operates as a key criterion for aesthetic success. At that moment, image analysis is reduced to a search for formal correspondences, and the viewer stops questioning the historical time, the function of the image, the technical device, the visual style, social circulation, cultural memory, and the type of attention the photograph solicits. As we anticipated in the previous article on the rule of thirds, this type of geometric analysis only succeeds after discarding all that information or those relationships that the rule does not explain.

2. Genealogy of a misattributed authority

A central difficulty in the discussion about the golden region is that its historical-cultural prestige relies on a genealogy frequently simplified to the point of error or historical distortion: Euclid described the division of a line in extreme and mean ratio, but Naini warns that in The Elements this proportion appears as a general geometric relationship, without linking it to beauty, nature, or an almost mystical property of perception (Naini, 2024). The conversion of that mathematical relationship into a universal principle of beauty is much later. According to Naini’s review, the strong attribution of the golden section to the beauty of nature, the body, and art intensifies in the 19th century with Adolf Zeising (a pioneer of objectivist aesthetics), continues with experimental and architectural receptions such as Fechner and Le Corbusier, and reaches contemporary popular literature with a considerable degree of uncritical repetition (Naini, 2024).

This point forces us to correct an overly comfortable formulation of the objectivist hypothesis: it is not enough to say that the golden region simply belongs to the aesthetics of classical Greece. It would be more precise to state that the golden region has been used in modern times to construct an image of classical Greece as the origin of a mathematical aesthetics of beauty. That proposal is not unrelated to ancient elements: proportion, number, harmony, symmetry, and canon were important categories in different Greek frameworks. However, the specific identification between the golden proportion and universal beauty cannot be retrospectively projected as if it were an established classical doctrine. Naini also shows that widely repeated claims about the Parthenon, Leonardo, or the Mona Lisa rely on weak diagrammatic adjustments and chains of authority rather than documentary evidence or controlled measurements (Naini, 2024).

It is advisable, however, to add a historical precision: in Antiquity, there was no psychology of aesthetic perception comparable to the modern one, interested in experimentally describing subjective processes of attention, pleasure, memory, or judgment. This does not mean that the Greeks ignored the experience of beauty, but some of their most influential philosophical traditions tended to think of it as recognition of an intelligible, normative, or ontological order. The Pythagorean tradition linked number, proportion, and harmonia (relationship among elements) with forms of order; but it would be anachronistic to turn that relationship into a demonstrated theory according to which a geometric structure would uniformly produce pleasure in any observer. And it would be even less defensible to identify that horizon with the golden proportion, whose strong association with universal beauty is, as noted, a much later construction.

The so-called Canon of Polykleitos allows us to specify this difference: we know his doctrine indirectly and late, mainly through Galen’s testimony, who describes it as a precise relationship between parts of the body: finger to finger, fingers to hand, hand to forearm, and each part to the whole. However, no original table of proportions or unique formula survives that would allow equating it with the golden number. The canon does not demonstrate a natural law of beauty; rather, it expresses an ideal of formal correctness produced in a specific sculptural context. Aristotle also linked beauty with order, proportion, and determination, but he did not reduce these categories to a singular mathematical constant.

The later Greco-Roman tradition maintained the importance of measure but combined it with criteria of convenience, function, and context. Vitruvius spoke of order, arrangement, eurhythmia (harmonious movement), symmetry, and decorum; and admitted that proportions should adjust to place, use, and visual effects. Horace and Quintilian, from poetics and rhetoric, reinforced the centrality of adequacy, clarity, and judgment, not a geometric law applicable indiscriminately to every work. Classical measure should thus be understood as an attribute of quality inscribed in determined technical, social, and institutional conventions. The golden region later acquired a legitimizing function: it offered that historical constellation an apparently exact and universal relationship, which today is extrapolated to photographs and artistic horizons in a totally anachronistic way.

The history of the arts allows us to expand this diagnosis: Kristeller argued that the modern system of fine arts, formed around painting, sculpture, architecture, music, and poetry, did not acquire a defined shape before the 18th century, although it gathered materials from Antiquity, the Middle Ages, and the Renaissance (Kristeller, 1951, 1952). In Antiquity, technē and ars did not designate the fine arts in the modern sense, but teachable activities, trades, knowledge, and techniques. The modern grouping of the arts under a general theory of aesthetic experience is, therefore, a historical construction. Shiner develops this same thesis by describing the modern division between art and craft, artist and artisan, aesthetic contemplation and function, as the result of institutional, social, and economic transformations of the 18th and 19th centuries (Shiner, 2001).

A classic recurring example of reframing a work to fit a supposed golden ratio or golden spiral involves discarding part of the work until an aspect ratio and geometric relationship that meets such a ratio is found. Image source: fstoppers.com

The consequence for visual analysis is broad: if the modern concept of art itself is historically situated, so is the way of questioning the beauty of an image. Applying a golden template to a medieval painting, a documentary photograph, a surrealist image, or a war scene can not only be methodologically fragile; it can be conceptually improper. The image was not necessarily produced to materialize an ideal of proportional harmony, nor was it received in its context as an autonomous object of formal contemplation. The anachronism consists in turning a reading category, constructed from modern needs of aesthetic legitimation, into a supposedly historically transversal cause of value.

3. Photography and the illusion of objective composition

Contemporary photography intensifies this problem because it combines two traits that strain any rigid formalist theory: on the one hand, photography is the art of framing: it selects, orders, excludes, hierarchizes, and visually stabilizes a fragment of the world; on the other hand, it maintains a constitutive relationship with contingency, the instant, the device, the technical trace, social circulation, and the documentary or fictional status of the image. When golden analysis is applied to photography, it tends to privilege the first trait and ignore the second. The image appears as a closed, almost pictorial composition, where everything seems to respond to a rigorously planned geometric necessity. Thus, the temporal and technical character of the photographic is lost in favor of tightening methodological ties with painting in an exercise of legitimation.

Again, part of the framing or field of view is discarded from the analysis until a supposed correlation with the spiral or golden regions with some elements of the scene is achieved. This type of careless analysis is common since practically no photographic aspect ratio coincides with that 1.6 ratio. This forces discarding part of the work until the illusion of correlation is achieved. Image source: Elliot McGucken

Shiner reminds us that photography was progressively assimilated into the fine arts system, not because it was born already installed in it, but because its uses, institutions, and audiences negotiated and consolidated its status (Shiner, 2001). This observation is especially relevant for the critical review of the golden region.

Many geometric readings of photographs fulfill a legitimizing function.

These readings show that a photographic image participates in a traditional compositional order, deliberately planned and, therefore, worthy of being understood as art. But that legitimation can impoverish what photography precisely contributed as a solution to a modern problem: the relationship between document and construction, chance and decision, technical automatism and intention, mechanical reproducibility and a singular appearance.

In contemporary painting or photography, the value of an image may come from its imbalance, its uncomfortable frontality, its deliberate banality, its relationship with an archive, its political inscription, its institutional irony, or its way of deactivating perceptual expectations. Conway and Rehding emphasize that art, beauty, and perception should not be confused, as there are deeply relevant works that are not beautiful in a harmonic sense, and because notions of beauty vary culturally and historically (Conway & Rehding, 2013). The example of Goya’s Saturn Devouring His Son, used by these authors, is useful because it shows that an intense aesthetic experience can articulate horror, violence, disproportion, and strangeness, not only harmony or beauty.

4. Neuroaesthetics: from the rule to the interaction of systems

Neuroaesthetics does not confirm the myth of a mathematical key to beauty; rather, it displaces it. Contemporary models tend to describe the aesthetic experience as the result of perceptual, affective, semantic, attentional, and contextual processes that interact over time. Leder and Nadal, reviewing the model of the aesthetic episode, insist that art appreciation includes stages of perceptual analysis, implicit memory integration, explicit classification, cognitive mastery, and continuous emotional evaluation (Leder & Nadal, 2014). The work does not reach an empty spectator; it reaches a subject with learning, expectations, familiarity, categories, prior information, and affective dispositions (see previous entry on value construction).

The processing fluency theory helps understand why certain formally ordered traits can be pleasurable without turning them into absolute universals. Reber, Schwarz, and Winkielman propose that aesthetic pleasure increases when the object is processed more easily, relating that fluency to variables such as symmetry, figure-ground contrast, repetition, prototypicality, and perceptual or conceptual priming (see final note) (Reber et al., 2004). This theory connects with some elements that objectivist aesthetics had already highlighted but changes their status: symmetry or proportion are not beautiful because they are metaphysical properties of the object, but because they can facilitate certain processing dynamics under specific conditions. Beauty, in this framework, is not simply in the object nor simply in the subject, but in the processing experience that emerges from their relationship.

Research on context confirms this orientation: Kirk et al. showed that the same set of abstract images received higher aesthetic ratings when labeled as coming from a gallery than when presented as computer-generated, and that this contextual modulation correlated with activity in medial orbitofrontal and prefrontal cortices (Kirk et al., 2009). Huang et al. studied the assignment of authenticity in works attributed to Rembrandt and concluded that the aesthetic experience of a work is modified by social and expert information, through multiple brain networks and not by a single cortical area (Huang et al., 2011). Sun et al., in a recent study on visual complexity, information, and affective valence (see final note), show that the representation of an image’s complexity is modulated by available information, familiarity, knowledge, and valence, and that this representation influences judgments of liking and understanding (Sun et al., 2025).

These results are difficult to reconcile with an explicit golden ratio: if aesthetic value depended on a privileged geometric proportion, semantic information, institutional attribution, authenticity, familiarity, observation task, or affective-symbolic state should occupy a secondary place. The reviewed evidence indicates quite the opposite. Visual form does not disappear but is integrated into a broader system. Cela-Conde et al. point out that aesthetic appreciation involves reward, attention, emotion, memory, and evaluation processes, and that neuroimaging techniques only capture fragments of a complex experience (Cela-Conde et al., 2011). Chatterjee and Vartanian, in the formulation of the aesthetic triad, organize that complexity into the interaction of sensorimotor systems, emotion-valuation systems, and knowledge-meaning systems, a framework also applied to architectural experience (Chatterjee et al., 2021; Li & Zhang, 2020).

From this perspective, the golden region may be one of many configurations that facilitate order, orientation, or perceptual prediction, but it does not decipher the key to taste. It may contribute to fluency in some cases, compete with other principles in others, or be irrelevant when the experience depends on semantic tension, expectation violation, ambiguity, or a specific historical context. Neuroaesthetics, when used cautiously, does not return formalism a simple scientific legitimacy; rather, it forces more precise questions about which image traits are processed, by whom, under what task, with what information, and within which culture or visual context.

An especially pertinent experimental contrast is offered by Stieger and Swami (2015), who compared artistic images with the motif placed in the golden ratio, in the center, and, in a third study, in an alternative asymmetric three-quarter position. Explicit evaluations and implicit measures via response times did not reveal an automatic and general preference for the golden ratio. On the contrary, in the first two studies, implicit valuation consistently favored the central position, a result the authors relate to early preference for symmetry. The slight explicit advantage of the golden ratio over the three-quarter position also disappeared when controlling for knowledge and interest in art. The result does not allow turning the golden region into a perceptual law: if any conscious preference exists, it seems to depend on learning and aesthetic competence. The off-center position may attract attention due to its salience against a symmetrical visual environment, but the experiment did not find that the golden position had an automatic advantage over another asymmetric position (Stieger & Swami, 2015).

5. Diversity, universality, and limits of explainability

Part of the appeal of the golden region comes from its promise to reconcile diversity and universality. Images are infinitely varied, but the number seems to offer a transversal explanation. Contemporary neuroaesthetics poses the question differently; Nadal and Chatterjee argue that art is both universal and diverse: universal because it depends on neurobiological systems common to the human species, and diverse because those systems are flexible, context-sensitive, modulated by learning, and transformed by individual and cultural experience (Nadal & Chatterjee, 2019). Universality does not require formal invariance; it may reside precisely in the plasticity of mechanisms that allow producing and appreciating very different forms.

Zaidel et al. reach a similar conclusion from archaeology and evolution. Any explanation of the origin of art and aesthetic experience must attend to gradual and coevolutionary processes, not a sudden appearance of a unique formal canon (Zaidel et al., 2013). Remains of pigments, ornaments, marks, and symbolic artifacts predating European figurative art cannot be reduced to an ideal proportion aesthetic. Their relevance seems linked to communication, identity, social signaling, symbolization, and bodily or ritual practices. In that framework, seeking a golden template as the foundation of human aesthetic behavior would impoverish the variety of functions that visual forms have fulfilled.

The golden region may maintain an indirect connection with real perceptual phenomena: symmetry, regularity, balance, grouping, fluency, prototypicality, moderate complexity, or hierarchical order. But those phenomena are not equivalent to 1.618. The literature on visual complexity shows that aesthetic judgments depend on both quantitative and structural components, and that familiarity, prior information, and expert knowledge modify perceived complexity (Sun et al., 2025). Similarly, eye-tracking studies remind us that gaze movements vary according to paintings, observers, group differences, task, and context (Rosenberg & Klein, 2015). A spiral superimposed a posteriori does not tell us how a viewer actually looked, what information guided their attention, or what value they attributed to what was observed.

The golden ratio leaves us at a superficial level of explanation, just as the famous “rule of thirds” can be a didactic convention to train compositional sensitivity. It can be an explicit principle if an author documents it in their work process or manifesto; it can be a measurable hypothesis if anchor points, corpus, controls, and comparisons with other proportions are defined. What it cannot be is a universal key that explains or guarantees the beauty of images produced under historical, technical, and symbolic regimes that are not only heterogeneous but widely disparate.

6. Foundations of formal image analysis

A responsible analysis should meet at least four conditions:

The first is historical: before asserting that a work corresponds to the golden region, it should be shown that this proportion was part of the technical, theoretical, or documentary horizon of the author, workshop, school, or visual culture under judgment. In the absence of such evidence, the hypothesis must be presented as a contemporary reading, not as the author’s intention.

The second condition is methodological: measurement points must be defined before seeking the fit, and the result must be compared with alternative proportions. In photography, this is especially important because cropping, aspect ratio, enlargement, printed copy, screen display, and editorial editing can alter perceived composition. If a spiral only fits after shifting, scaling, inverting, or selectively choosing some points and not others, the analysis approaches geometric pareidolia or confirmation bias rather than reasoned explanation. It is important to remember that the vast majority of aspect ratios of films, photographic plates, or sensors do not meet the 1.618 ratio, as they are simply the result of industrial conventions and standards.

The third condition is perceptual: a distinction must be made between image structure and the observer’s visual behavior; a photograph may contain a proportional relationship without that relationship guiding the gaze, and the gaze may be guided by contrast, face, gesture, text, focus, color, threat, body direction, or prior knowledge, even if none of those variables is golden. Research on perception of paintings using eye-tracking shows that gaze does not respond solely to composition understood as a fixed geometric structure, but also to the observer, the task, and the context (Rosenberg & Klein, 2015).

The fourth condition is aesthetic: beauty, artistic value, taste, interest, understanding, pleasure, unease, sublimity, strangeness, and cultural relevance must be separated. The modern tradition has tended to make beauty the center of aesthetics, but even within that tradition, modern and contemporary art has repeatedly displaced harmonic beauty as a privileged trait (Conway & Rehding, 2013; Leder & Nadal, 2014). An image can be valuable for reasons other than harmony, and a harmonic image can be banal because it does not carry sufficient symbolic weight to endow it with some singularity.

7. Conclusion

The abuse of the golden region in the analysis of contemporary photographs or even in pictorial work is not a purely methodological error. It is a symptom of a deeper aspiration: the desire to resolve aesthetic uncertainty through a form of immediate visual objectivity. That desire has a long history and connects with traditions that have sought in number, proportion, and symmetry a guarantee of beauty. As the character Sol Robeson states in Pi, faith in chaos (Darren Aronofsky, 1998), one must not confuse mathematics with numerology […] if you want to find a number, you will find it everywhere. The golden region, as it circulates today in many image analyses, is not the survival of a classical truth but a sedimented cultural construction, with strong modern, nineteenth-century, and popular components, whose repetition tends to present as proof what is only a possible reading.

Contemporary photography, precisely because of its link to the mechanical device or automatism, time, contingency of the field of view, archive, social circulation, and ambiguity of its artistic status, clearly shows the limits of this compositional reductionism. When a spiral becomes the total explanation of a scene, it nullifies what the image has of historical, technical, semantic, and symbolic, reducing the complexity of the photographic act to an insufficient scheme. Beauty, taste, and artistic value cannot be deciphered through a geometric relationship but as an experience of interaction.

The golden ratio, as a local hypothesis, is debatable; as a universal canon, it impoverishes the polysemy of the image. As a cultural symptom, however, it is revealing: it shows our difficulty in accepting that aesthetic experience cannot be reduced to the object, the subject, or the number, but emerges from a changing web of perception, memory, context, learning, expectation, and meaning. Its persistence also reveals that the legitimation of photography within the fine arts continues to condition some ways of reading it.

The repeated and uncritical mention of the golden region — as happens with the “rule of thirds” — not only consolidates careless theories and fragile methodologies; it also naturalizes a way of seeing based on precepts presented as immanent qualities of the object and guarantees of rigorous judgment.

Notes:

Prototypicality: Refers to the tendency to respond favorably to stimuli perceived as familiar exemplars or representatives of a visual category. Processing fluency theory proposes that prototypes can be attractive when processed with relative ease, although this relationship depends on context, task, and the observer’s prior experience.

Priming (facilitation): is an effect whereby prior exposure to a stimulus can facilitate or modify the processing of a subsequent one. In art appreciation, semantic or contextual information can influence aesthetic evaluation; for example, attributing an image to a particular author can modify the observer’s response.

Affective valence: describes the evaluative dimension of an experience, situated on a continuum from liking to disliking. In neuroaesthetics, it allows analyzing how the perception of an image can be associated with affective and motivational responses, without reducing its meaning or value to an automatic reaction.

See previous articles:

Context reading: for a historical introduction to the comparison between the golden ratio and the rule of thirds, see “The rule of thirds vs golden ratio: myths and legends”.

Bibliography

Cela-Conde, C. J., Agnati, L., Huston, J. P., Mora, F., & Nadal, M. (2011). The neural foundations of aesthetic appreciation. Progress in Neurobiology, 94(1), 39-48.

Chatterjee, A. (2014). The aesthetic brain: How we evolved to desire beauty and enjoy art. Oxford University Press.

Chatterjee, A., Coburn, A., & Weinberger, A. B. (2021). The neuroaesthetics of architectural spaces. Cognitive Processing.

Conway, B. R., & Rehding, A. (2013). Neuroaesthetics and the trouble with beauty. PLoS Biology, 11(3), e1001504.

Huang, M., Bridge, H., Kemp, M. J., & Parker, A. J. (2011). Human cortical activity evoked by the assignment of authenticity when viewing works of art. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 5, 134.

Kant, I. (2001 [1790]). Critique of the power of judgment. Cambridge University Press.

Kirk, U., Skov, M., Hulme, O., Christensen, M. S., & Zeki, S. (2009). Modulation of aesthetic value by semantic context: An fMRI study. NeuroImage, 44(3), 1125-1132.

Kristeller, P. O. (1951). The modern system of the arts: A study in the history of aesthetics Part I. Journal of the History of Ideas, 12(4), 496-527.

Kristeller, P. O. (1952). The modern system of the arts: A study in the history of aesthetics (II). Journal of the History of Ideas, 13(1), 17-46.

Leder, H., & Nadal, M. (2014). Ten years of a model of aesthetic appreciation and aesthetic judgments: The aesthetic episode – Developments and challenges in empirical aesthetics. British Journal of Psychology, 105(4), 443-464.

Li, R., & Zhang, J. (2020). Review of computational neuroaesthetics: Bridging the gap between neuroaesthetics and computer science. Brain Informatics, 7, 16.

Nadal, M., & Chatterjee, A. (2019). Neuroaesthetics and art’s diversity and universality. WIREs Cognitive Science, 10(3), e1487.

Naini, F. B. (2024). The golden ratio – dispelling the myth. Maxillofacial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 46, 2.

Reber, R., Schwarz, N., & Winkielman, P. (2004). Processing fluency and aesthetic pleasure: Is beauty in the perceiver’s processing experience? Personality and Social Psychology Review, 8(4), 364-382.

Rosenberg, R., & Klein, C. (2015). The moving eye of the beholder: Eye tracking and the perception of paintings. In J. P. Huston, M. Nadal, F. Mora, L. F. Agnati, & C. J. Cela Conde (Eds.), Art, aesthetics, and the brain. Oxford University Press.

Shiner, L. (2001). The invention of art: A cultural history. University of Chicago Press.

Stieger, S., & Swami, V. (2015). Time to let go? No automatic aesthetic preference for the golden ratio in art pictures. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 9(1), 91–102.

Sun, X., Che, J., Nadal, M., & Leder, H. (2025). Information and affective valence influence judgments of complexity, liking and understanding. British Journal of Psychology.

Zaidel, D. W., Nadal, M., Flexas, A., & Munar, E. (2013). An evolutionary approach to art and aesthetic experience. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 7(1), 100-109.