The article titled “Brightness Perception in Complex Fields,” written by Bartleson and Breneman in 1967, examines how brightness is perceived in complex fields such as photographic reproductions, taking into account different lighting levels and environmental conditions. The authors conducted brightness scaling experiments using two methods: magnitude estimation and interocular brightness matching with a haploscopic colorimeter.
Historically, various predictive equations have been proposed to describe the relationship between perceived brightness and stimulus luminance. Among the most cited are Fechner’s, which suggests that brightness increases proportionally to the logarithm of luminance, and Stevens’, which states that brightness follows a power function of luminance. Stevens also indicated that variations in brightness can be described by a power group transformer that adjusts sensitivity and induction changes through a variable exponent. However, Jameson and Hurvich found that there are increasing deviations from the power form when induction effects are considered.
The experiments conducted by the authors, performed with complex photographic images viewed in both illuminated and dark environments, revealed that brightness functions do not follow a simple power function. Instead, they show an exponential decay from the power form, indicating non-linearity in log-log coordinates. The data obtained suggest that brightness perception in complex fields can be described by an equation incorporating both a power term and an exponential decay term. The experimental results indicated systematic variations in brightness with lighting levels and observation environment conditions.
The authors found that even in the absence of environmental stimuli, a photographic image can act as its own induction field. In the presence of a reference “white” within the image or surrounding environment, scene elements with lower luminances tend to have predictable perceived brightness. Furthermore, when the brightnesses of a complex image are considered relative to the brightness of a reference “white,” the shape of the relative brightness function changes little with different lighting levels but is significantly affected by viewing conditions such as dark or illuminated environments.
In conclusion, the study demonstrates that brightness perceptions of elements in complex scenes, such as photographic reproductions, are not well described by a simple power function of luminance. They invoke the need for a more complex description that includes induction factors and stimulus context. These findings are of particular interest for the evaluation of photographic reproductions and suggest caution in generalizing predictive brightness models to other significantly different viewing situations.
