The article “UV-Vis-NIR Reflectance Spectroscopy of Red Lakes in Paintings” by Christina Bisulca, Marcello Picollo, Mauro Bacci, and Diane Kunzelman, published in 2008, addresses the use of UV-Vis-NIR fiber optic reflectance spectroscopy (FORS) for the non-invasive identification of red dyes in paintings. The red dyes historically used by artists mainly originate from compounds based on the chemical structure of anthraquinone, derived from insects such as cochineal carmine and kermes, or from plants such as madder, which contain alizarin and purpurin. The precise identification of these dyes is crucial for conservation and historical art research. The traditionally used technique for this identification is high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), which is destructive, time-consuming, and requires complicated sample preparation. Techniques such as Raman spectroscopy and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) are also employed, but they present significant limitations such as fluorescence and low dye concentration, respectively.
FORS spectroscopy offers several advantages: it is a non-invasive technique, highly sensitive to dyes, and does not require samples. However, the identification of dyes in actual paintings presents challenges due to interference from other pigments and the effects of natural aging of the paint, which can mask or modify spectral features. In the study, replicas were prepared using red dyes in various typical tempera painting applications, including red dye glazes over lead white and vermilion, as well as mixtures with different concentrations of lead white. These preparations were analyzed to evaluate FORS’s ability to identify red dyes in paintings.
The results showed characteristic patterns in the reflectance spectra, mainly in the visible region, with strong absorption bands between 500-560 nm, a reflectance peak around 420 nm, and a pronounced increase in reflectance from 600 nm towards the NIR. Preparations with low concentration allowed better characterization of the dyes, demonstrating FORS’s sensitivity. At higher concentrations, the absorption intensity increases to the point that only strong absorption in the visible region is observed, instead of the characteristic bands. It was observed that thin and transparent dye layers over vermilion mask many visible features, making dye identification difficult.
The study concludes that FORS is effective for detecting the presence of anthraquinone-based dyes and, in some cases, identifying their origin (insect vs. plant) through characteristic sub-bands of absorption in the visible region. However, the technique may not be sufficient for precise identification under all conditions, particularly when the dye is concentrated or mixed with a highly absorbing pigment. Further research is required to understand how other paint preparations, different classes and manufactures of dyes, as well as aging, affect reflectance spectra before drawing definitive conclusions from FORS spectra in studies of actual paintings.
