The article “Effect of Aliasing on the MTF of Digital Photographic Cameras” by Carles Mitjà and Jaume Escofet addresses the implications of the aliasing effect on the modulation transfer function (MTF) of digital SLR cameras. These cameras, equipped with CCD or CMOS sensors, often face a problem because the sensor’s sampling frequency is lower than the input signal frequency, resulting in a false replica of that signal known as aliasing.
Manufacturers install anti-aliasing filters to counteract these negative effects, limiting the input signal to a frequency close to the system’s Nyquist frequency. However, the effectiveness of these filters is crucial for the final image quality. In the study, two SLR camera bodies with different characteristics but a similar resolution limit were equipped using the same lens, a Micro Nikkor 55mm f/3.5. The influence of aliasing was evaluated by measuring the lens’s resolving power and the MTF of the lens-camera system.
The lens’s resolving power was limited solely by diffraction. By observing the image of the USAF1951 target, it was confirmed that the resolution exceeds the sensors’ limit, except in cases of f/22 and f/32 apertures where diffraction reduced the resolution. In the tests, the Nikon D70 showed considerably high modulation factor values near the Nyquist frequency, while the Nikon D700 demonstrated consistency in the system’s response at different apertures, except for the f/32 aperture limited by diffraction.
It was concluded that the Nikon D70, due to its low efficiency low-pass filter, introduces a significant uncertainty factor regarding the expected quality of results in scenes with random frequency content. In contrast, the Nikon D700, with consistent behavior against the frequency content of the input signal, eliminates this uncertainty at the cost of a moderate MTF result at medium and low frequencies. This behavior is conditioned by the cutoff frequency of the camera’s anti-aliasing filter.
In summary, the study reveals that camera systems affected by aliasing present clear differences in the MTF, particularly marked by the effectiveness of the anti-aliasing filter and behavior at the Nyquist frequency. The tests performed demonstrate that a camera with a more efficient filter, such as the Nikon D700, provides more consistent and predictable results, despite showing less impressive MTF values at medium and low frequencies.
