The article “When is it advisable to improve the quality of camera lenses?” written by Dr. J. Kämmerer, deeply discusses the determining factors of image quality in camera lenses and the circumstances under which an improvement in the quality of these lenses is practical and beneficial.
To address the topic, Kämmerer begins by exploring the definition of image quality and how it can be quantified objectively. He focuses on the modulation transfer function (MTF), which describes the optical quality of an image by representing the contrast transfer depending on the size of details, measured in cycles per millimeter (cycles/mm). Image quality is also evaluated from the subjective perception of the human observer, indicating that there is a numerical relationship between the area under the modulation transfer function curve and the perceived subjective quality of the image.
The author points out that in medium and miniature format photography, the spatial frequency range above 40 cycles/mm has minimal influence on perceived quality. Therefore, it is proposed to limit the analysis to spatial frequencies between 0 and 40 cycles/mm. This evaluation method is essential because, in practice, the image observation process involves a whole chain of transfer functions involved at different stages such as the lens, the film, the projector (in the case of slide projection), and finally the human eye.
Kämmerer suggests that an improvement in the quality of camera lenses is only justifiable when this improvement is perceptible in terms of image quality, that is, when it results in a significant increase in the modulation transfer factor. He proposes that such improvement should be on the order of approximately 0.1 in a range of 20 cycles/mm, always considering that the subjective perception of quality must be reasonably proportional to the costs associated with such improvement.
The author also discusses the challenges in mass production of high-quality lenses, exposing the need for precise measuring devices, such as the KVl lens testers used by Zeiss, to ensure uniform quality in production. Furthermore, he points out the importance of maintaining strict production tolerances to avoid significant fluctuations in image quality.
Examples of improvements are introduced through the use of new materials, such as FK 51 type glass which considerably reduces longitudinal chromatic aberrations in telephoto lenses, and the introduction of the floating element principle, which allows improving image quality at close focusing distances in wide-angle lenses.
Finally, he points out the importance of film flatness throughout the image capture process. Through recent measurements, Kämmerer shows that film curvature can negatively affect image quality, especially in fast lenses. The research demonstrates that the characteristics of the film cartridge influence film curvature, suggesting that an adaptation of the cartridge design could mitigate these problems.
