Critical review of definitions of metamerism

0
344

The article titled “Critical review of definitions of metamerism” written by Alan R. Robertson in 1983 thoroughly examines the various definitions of metamerism used in color science and industrial painting. The author highlights the discrepancies between the definitions of color scientists and industrial colorists, suggesting that the communication gap between these two groups can be overcome through small modifications in existing definitions and clearer terminology. Robertson considers this divergence resolvable through education and the correct interpretation of terms.

For color scientists, a fundamental definition of metamerism is when two different chromatic stimuli generate the same color under the same observation conditions, this property being attributed to the spectral power distribution of the stimuli. However, this definition seems to conflict with common industry practice, which refers to metamerism as a property of the objects themselves. Robertson resolves this contradiction by proposing that metameric objects are those which, when illuminated by a reference light source, reflect stimuli with different spectral power distributions, producing the same color under specific observation conditions.

Furthermore, Robertson introduces the idea of a “reference observer,” recognizing that color matching functions may vary between observers, which could lead to two stimuli not matching for different observers. This notion of reference observers and illuminants facilitates a more precise understanding of metamerism and its conditional nature, where a “conditional match” can be broken by changing the observation conditions.

The article also emphasizes that metamerism should not be confused with color perceptual constancy, which is the independence of the perceived color of an object from changes in the spectral distribution of the light source. Although both concepts are related, they are distinct phenomena. Two objects that metamerically match under a reference light source generally will not do so under other lights, implying a lack of constancy in at least one of them. However, lack of color constancy is not an indicator of metamerism, as two objects may not physically match yet still exhibit a lack of color constancy.

Robertson also criticizes several “non-definitions” of metamerism that describe causes or effects of the phenomenon rather than defining it properly. For example, the idea that “metamerism occurs when the color difference between two samples changes with illumination” is not an exact definition, although it could be clarified by saying “when metamerism occurs, the color difference between samples may change with illumination.”

Finally, to address practical use in industry, Robertson suggests terms such as “metameric match” and “metameric mismatch.” A metameric match is defined as a match under a specific illuminant that breaks under another; this helps avoid confusion and improves terminological precision.

In summary, Robertson’s article offers a critical and thorough review of the definitions of metamerism, proposing improvements and clarifications that can help unify terminology between color science and industry, and resolves persistent misunderstandings through precise definitions and detailed observations.

Review on the publisher’s website