WorkFlow: Raw Developers and Color Profiles

0
635

One of the topics I had left pending until this short article is the relationship between the color spaces we use to output from our RAW developers and the color spaces used to create our Test Charts*, which will be used to create our color profiles, whether with RoughProfiler, Argyll, or other similar profiling software.

All these profiling programs will read the RGB values of the color patches from the digital capture of our color chart (Test Chart) and use them for the calculations to generate a profile from this Test Chart.

Adobe Camera RAW (and Adobe LightRoom)

The problem we face is that when we develop a RAW with developers like ACR, we are forced to generate our TIFFs with a specific profile: sRGB, ProPhoto RGB, ColorMatch, or Adobe RGB.

comparativa_RGB_proPhotoIf we perform some tests, for example generating the same image with ProPhoto and sRGB, we will observe that the appearance of the images is identical, except when our image contains very saturated colors, where ProPhoto performs better than sRGB.

We will therefore observe that our image has the same LAB values, but it has different RGB values. And this is precisely where our problem lies, since our profiling program will use these RGB values and therefore different values mean different results!

This is relatively true. Personally, I always work with the same color spaces, that is, if I start by creating my Test Chart in sRGB, all my subsequent photos I develop in sRGB.

Output Test Chart ΔE*
ProPhoto X 10,7
ProPhoto ProPhoto 3,3
ProPhoto sRGB 14,4
sRGB X 10,3
sRGB sRGB 2,9
sRGB ProPhoto 36,2

Output: It is the profile chosen for the output of all the images in our project to which we will assign the profile generated with the Test Chart. The records marked with X indicate that no custom profile has been assigned. ΔE* is the difference between the colors of our color chart and those recorded after its digital capture.

However, if we do not maintain this consistency, for example, if we create the Test Chart in sRGB and develop our images, to which we will later assign our profile created from that Test Chart, in ProPhoto, we will encounter a major inconsistency problem in our color management workflow.

The procedure to follow, according to the previous table, is clear: Always use the same space, both for the Test Chart and for the rest of the images to which we will assign the profile created with that Test Chart. Never mix color spaces.

At this point, it would be necessary to revisit the article “All about DNG camera profiles” since the concept of calibration will also influence profiling operations, so this parameter must also be kept constant.

Capture ONE

This fabulous editor, underestimated compared to the Adobe empire, presents a more rational workflow around color management.

capture_one_controlsCapture ONE presents two areas for color space control: a first called “Base Characteristics” where what could be called camera profiles or Look profiles are assigned, and a second control in the output menu, with an approach similar to ACR, but much richer in possibilities. The first control “assigns” a profile and the second “converts” to a color space.

If we want to generate a Test Chart, we must disable the output color space with an “Integrate camera profile” and limit ourselves to defining the first control based on the camera profile.

comparativa_capture_oneIf we make a small comparison, we can observe that despite assigning one or another camera profile, the appearance varies, so LAB is different, but RGB remains the same. This means that Capture ONE performs a “color management free” development and then assigns the profile, so the operation is reversible, unlike ACR which converts our image to a specific space, thus preserving LAB values but changing RGB values.


Note: By Test Chart, I refer to the image or capture of our color chart, which will be used by the ICC color profile creation software to obtain the spectral values of this capture, in order to compare them with its reference file.