Since the popularization of digital capture techniques in the late 1990s, the digital image has been proposed as a modern strategy for the preservationand dissemination of cultural heritage. At that time, digital technologies offered us significant accessibility, and above all immediacy and control possibilities, which physical-chemical capture had not yet fully provided.
Thus, institutions (such as the IAPH) and professionals have very early joined digitization policies, that is, massive digitization plans of documentary or heritage collections in general, in order to ensure their preservation and facilitate their dissemination or access by the general public. In many cases, this has turned heritage digitization tasks into mere technological experiments, unrelated to any policy of preservation or dissemination of a cultural asset.
At the same time that digital capture techniques became part of cultural heritage preservation strategies through museums, archives, and other institutions, concerns began to arise about the suitability of this new medium as a tool for preserving the heritage itself.
Since the late 1980s, and particularly the early 1990s, we find authors such as Kirk Martinez (MARTINEZ; HAMBER, 1989) or David R. Saunders (SAUNDERS; HAMBER, 1990) who, from institutions like the National Gallery or the British Museum, began early to delve into the issues of digital imaging in cultural heritage. These works led to projects such as the VASARI digital image capture project, developed between the late 1980s and early 1990s (SAUNDERS; CUPITT, 1993), as well as many other experimental projects carried out during that decade and duly collected in the work Ten years of art imaging research (MARTINEZ; CUPITT; SAUNDERS et al., 2002).
Similarly, during this same period, archaeologists such as Robert Bednarik (BEDNARIK, 1991) began reflecting on the relevance of digital imaging as scientific data in the context of rock art, or as a means for diagnosis or study of a cultural asset (SAUNDERS, 1989).
The problem or question seemed evident: if the digital image can be presented as a means of preservation or understanding of certain information of a cultural asset in the future, evidently, the transfer of information between artifact and image must be sufficiently precise to ensure the correct representation of the work or, at least, certain attributes of it in this new digital medium.
Parallel to this concern, throughout the 1990s the International Color Consortium (ICC) color standards appeared and were established, which structure much of the current color management workflows, with evident significance in the digitization problem, as well as committees such as the ANSI IT8 that introduce certain standards in digitization matters.
Entering the new millennium, works such as those by Robyn Myers (2000), Roy Berns (2001), Murphy (2005), or Peter Burns and Don Williams (2001) definitively shaped a latent problem, namely the fidelity of digital reproduction or representation of a cultural asset or artwork.
Thus, throughout the first decade of the 2000s, various compilations of recommendations began to timidly emerge, such as the Technical Guidelines for Digitizing Cultural Heritage Materials in the USA around 2004, or the Metamorfoze project in the Netherlands (published in 2012 but already being developed since the late 1990s), which discuss from a technical point of view the quality attributes of the digital image or capture system (tonal reproduction, acutance, noise, neutrality, uniformity, etc.) and their conformity thresholds, that is, what levels of error are acceptable in our digitization projects. In short, protocols and recommendations for quality control during digital capture, approached from a strictly technical perspective.
If we consult the bibliography or references in our country, we find the work of the Ministry of Culture Guidelines for digitization projects of collections and public domain holdings, particularly for those held in libraries and archives (IFLA; ICA; UNESCO, 2015), where a small effort is made to delve into some technical concepts regarding digitization. This vague approach to the problem at hand has not only remained a bibliographic rarity but rather a mere declaration of intent, as it is difficult to find continuity among the rest of the recommendations and actions undertaken in this field in our country since then.
Throughout the various digitization recommendations of recent decades in our country, we observe a clear orientation towards solving the problem of archiving, its management, or project management itself, and a very scarce intention to solve the multitude of technical problems related to the capture or formation of the digital image. And even, logically, there is significant concern about digital preservation, essentially focused on access to the digital document, but which rarely translates into the correct understanding of the data contained therein, such as colorimetric, spatial, tonal information, etc.
Thus, the very act of digitization, understood as the transfer of information from a “tangible” reality to a digital or numerical reality, remains completely detached from initiatives that address the relevance or precision of these processes.
Therefore, if the digitization of cultural heritage is approached as a strategy for its preservation, we are talking about a technical level of responsibility comparable to any other intervention on cultural heritage.That is, it must be undertaken within guarantees and rules that ensure the correct digital preservation and understanding of the artifact or digitized document in the future.
Therefore, digitization does not preserve the object, but the attributes that describe it and its content (shape, color, texture, iconic or formal reading, etc.); if these attributes are not transferred in their entirety or properly, we face an insufficient or distorted collection of information about our object. Information that will barely offer us a future understanding of the object itself, nor evidently sufficient information for its restitution in case of loss. Therefore, even ensuring the digital preservation of the computer file itself, the information it carries leaves us a significant margin of uncertainty in its interpretation because it does not come from a working method that has been subjected to properly tested and justified quality control.
Digitizing is not copying artifacts, but seeking their digital representation (ARILLO, 2014). Digitizing is collecting precise and sufficient information to be able to understand, replace, or restore the object in case of damage or loss. Therefore, we are not facing a mere photographic problem, as some professionals claim; that is, how we expose, illuminate, or process our digital images in a particular image editor. Nor is it strictly an archival or industrial problem based on processing the maximum number of artifacts in the shortest possible time, but rather a problem of cultural heritage preservation and, therefore, should be undertaken by professionals and intervention policies on the work, comparable to the level of responsibility of other fields of conservation and restoration of cultural goods.
Thus, the projects we carry out in quality control not only aim to improve image capture and processing workflows (greater colorimetric accuracy, greater detail, etc.) and archive management, but every quality control project involves tool characterization, which provides us with a greater understanding of them and, consequently, process optimization. In this way, it not only contributes to a quantitative improvement of certain attributes (lower colorimetric error, greater acutance, less noise, etc.) but also to an overall improvement in processes, which translates into strong task automation, error control systems, selection of more optimal equipment according to the needs of each project, etc. All these are key aspects that not only contribute to accuracy but also facilitate undertaking large digitization projects, optimizing costs and times without prejudice to the level of responsibility implied by any project linked to cultural heritage preservation.
Article originally published in the Revista PH September-December 2018. Special printed issue
Bibliography
ARILLO, J. R. (2014) Quality models in the digitization of photographic heritage. From the Magic Artifact to the Pixel. Madrid: Faculty of Documentation Sciences of the UCM, 2014, pp. 367-393
BEDNARIK, R. (1991) The IFRAO Standard Scale. Rock Art Research, 8, 1991, pp. 78-79
BERNS, R. S. (2001) The science of digitizing paintings for color-accurate image archives: a review. Journal of imaging science and technology, vol. 45, no. 4, 2001, pp. 305-325
BURNS, P. D.; WILLIAMS, D. R. (2001) Distilling noise sources for digital capture devices. Society for Imaging Science and Technology: Image Processing, Image Quality, Image Capture, Systems Conference. S.l.: s.n., 2001, pp. 132-136
DORMOLEN, H. VAN; GILLESSE, R.; REERINK, H. (2007) Metamorfoze Preservation Imaging Guidelines. The Hague: National Library of the Netherlands, 2007
FEDERAL AGENCIES DIGITIZATION INITIATIVE (2010) Technical Guidelines for Digitizing Cultural Heritage Materials: Creation of Raster Image Master Files [en línea]. Unpublished document. <http:// www.digitizationguidelines.gov/ guidelines/FADGI_Still_Image- Tech_Guidelines_2010-08-24.pdf> [Accessed: 07/04/2018]
IFLA; ICA; UNESCO (2005) Guidelines for digitization projects of collections and public domain holdings, particularly for those held in libraries and archives [en línea]. Madrid: Ministry of Culture, 2005. <https://www.mecd. gob.es/cultura-mecd/dms/mecd/ cultura-mecd/areas-cultura/archivos/ recursos-profesionales/documentos- tecnicos/pautas_digitalizacion.pdf> [Accessed: 07/04/2018]
MARTINEZ, K.; HAMBER, A. (1989) Towards a colorimetric digital image archive for the visual arts. Electronic Imaging Applications in Graphic Arts, vol. 1073, pp. 114-122
MARTINEZ, K.; CUPITT, J.; SAUNDERS, D. R. (1993) High-resolution colorimetric imaging of paintings. Cameras, Scanners, and Image Acquisition Systems. s. l.: International Society for Optics and Photonics, 1993, pp. 25-37
MARTINEZ, K.; CUPITT, J.; SAUNDERS, D.; PILLAY, R. (2002) Ten years of art imaging research. Proceedings of the IEEE, vol. 90, no. 1, 2002, pp. 28-41
MURPHY, E. P. (2005) A Testing Procedure to Characterize Color and Spatial Quality of Digital Cameras Used to Image Cultural Heritage. Unpublished doctoral thesis. Rochester Institute of Technology, 2005
Technology, 2005
MYERS, R. D. (2000) Color Accurate Digital Photography of Artworks [en línea]. Better Light, Inc., 2000. <http:// www.betterlight.com/downloads/ whitePaper/wp_color_accurate_photo. pdf> [Accessed: 07/12/2018]
SAUNDERS, D. (1989) The detection and measurement of colour change in paintings by digital image processing. Digital Image Processing Applications. s. l.: International Society for Optics and Photonics, 1989, pp. 405-416
