Words are unnecessary when we need to emphasize the importance of a good light source when facing projects that require good color reproduction, since light, together with the observer, is largely responsible for the usual problems of color reproduction.
However, it is worth asking, why do we want color management? If not to partially mitigate the defects produced by light sources on our colors. Indeed, this is the case; color management helps to alleviate reproduction problems caused by a poor illuminant. However, perhaps the best explanation of the importance of using good light sources lies in the TLCI (Television Lighting Consistency Index) scale, where, in addition to a numerical scale from 0-100%, these values are associated with the supposed ease of achieving good colors. One must consider that in cinema or TV there is no color management, but pure color correction; therefore, better lamps mean less correction work.
The same concept can be applied to color management: the better the light source, the more precision in our workflows, as less severe adjustments are necessary.
Throughout this website, I have already evaluated on various occasions light sources as well as their metrics, so in this article we will refer exclusively to LED light since it is a new light source not without controversy.
What is LED light?
An LED or Light Emitting Diode is nothing more than a semiconductor that, through an electroluminescence phenomenon between two types of semiconductor materials, emits light.
The great problem and challenge of LED light is that essentially it emits blue light, with a peak around 450nm, which must be compensated or manipulated in some way to emit white light. This is the role of the phosphor layer that covers the semiconductor matrix, which undergoes a Stokes shift due to fluorescence, as we can see in the graph on the left, so that we have a peak at 450nm and another peak or region that must try to cover the rest of the visible spectrum, which is usually the main problem when designing good LED light sources and is responsible for the white light itself by adding red and green to the spectrum that the semiconductor matrix naturally produces.
Advantages of LED light
LED light has penetrated almost every field of application in recent years, from living room lamps that replace fluorescent or incandescent bulbs to portable flashlights and even vehicle headlights. The advantages are high energy efficiency, meaning a lot of light with low consumption, along with long lifespan; therefore, LED light is proposed as the most optimal lighting source at present.
It should be noted that LED light is still under development; not only is there much to be done in terms of color reproduction, but also in energy efficiency.
“LED Panels”
LED lights themselves are small bulbs barely 5mm in diameter, and although powerful, it is necessary to aggregate them to emit light with some intensity, so LED lamps or light sources are usually called “panels” since they are a matrix of dozens or hundreds of small LED lights.
LED light and metrics
Throughout various articles, I have emphasized the paradoxes surrounding LED light regarding the metrics used to describe its quality. One of the main problems seems to lie in the lack of representativeness of the CRI (Color Render Index) metric for describing LED, since CRI was somewhat designed to describe fluorescent light and partly evaluates low chromaticity color samples. This type of evaluation reveals an aspect of LED light: it shows us colors with greater chromaticity which, due to the Hunt effect, appear more natural to our perception. That is why scales such as CQS (Color Quality Scale) or TLCI have recently been proposed.
All current metrics for characterizing light sources (CRI, CQS, and TLCI), although presenting some divergences, show a certain correlation.
On the other hand, all current color reproduction standards refer to the CRI metric, so unfortunately we are forced to establish correlations at the standardization level with the other metrics.
Analyzing a light source: the case of the F&V Z180 Ultracolor
F&V is a company perhaps unknown to many, but which has been in the market for nearly 10 years, very focused on LED lighting topics precisely, among other devices for cinema, television, and photography.
One of their flagship devices is the “Ultracolor” series of LED panels. In this case, we will examine an F&V 180 Ultracolor Daylight panel since they have other panels of different sizes and color temperatures, including variable color temperature, which are not relevant for our purpose.
This series is sold as daylight of approximately 5600K and a CRI > 90%, however, it should be noted that while in other light sources such as fluorescent and incandescent, with many more years of evolution, temperature and CRI are very constant, in LED light we have small variations depending on the manufacture of the LEDs.
Thus, in my F&V 180 Ultracolor panel, I obtain the following values, which, as we can see, are conditioned by the power at which we operate since these panels are dimmable:
| CCT | CRI | CQS | TLCI | Lumen (1m) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| min power | 5856 / D59 | 95 | 90 | 89 | 20,2 |
| max power | 5470 / D55 | 91 | 88 | 90 | 756 |
| min power + diffuser | 5689 / D57 | 95 | 90 | 89 | 17,6 |
| max power + diffuser | 5450 / D55 | 91 | 88 | 91 | 670 |
NOTE: The data shown are exclusive to the examined device and may vary during production.
This fluctuation of characteristics is very common in almost all light sources, but perhaps it is more relevant in LEDs. In any case, we see that regarding light quality, we remain within optimal ranges (CRI>90) and even if we take the TLCI metric, these panels are proposed as excellent in terms of color reproduction.
In the SPD (Spectral Power Distribution) graph of the F&V 180 Ultracolor, it can be clearly seen how the region corresponding to phosphor emission is shaped to cover as much as possible the green and red regions.
For example, if we take the set of 15 samples for the CQS evaluation, we see a worse score in the reproduction of blues, yet we appreciate a very good response in warm colors.
Another quite relevant aspect in the study of light sources is how diffusers behave regarding light quality. Diffusers are very common in LED panels since these have quite directional light. The F&V panels usually have, for example, an angle of about 65º, which translates into a light cone with a base of just over 1m in diameter at one meter distance. Therefore, in certain tasks, a diffuser is usually recommended.
In general, diffusers are simple translucent plastic sheets, which generally harm color reproduction considerably. However, it is interesting to note that the diffuser screens accompanying F&V lights do not affect quality metrics but almost exclusively affect light intensity and somewhat the color temperature.
Speaking of color temperature, if we look closely, it is the parameter that fluctuates the most; however, one might ask, is a constant color temperature relevant? From my point of view, and for some years now, phenomena related to color temperature are relatively easy to neutralize unless they are very extreme, which can cause noise to appear in certain channels due to excessive signal increase when balancing. On the other hand, it is rare to find light sources with precisely balanced color temperature, so color temperature management or dominant correction will always be required afterward.
Another curious aspect of F&V LED panels is that they can be combined to form larger panels, so that the light regulator of one controls the rest. This feature is quite relevant when scaling our equipment, whether acquiring new devices or, for example, traveling lighter.
Finally, another interesting topic is power supply; these F&V models can be powered in 3 ways: continuous power with a transformer connected to the electrical network, batteries like Sony NP-F550 (with just over 1 hour of autonomy), or 6 AA batteries, which although would be costly, using them in the studio or fieldwork is a highly recommended emergency option since these batteries are easy to acquire almost anywhere.
Therefore, LED light is proposed as an indispensable ally in fieldwork where we must carry energy with us and equipment weight is a constraint. Not only can we have good color reproduction quality, but also high energy efficiency. In the studio, LED light perhaps offers more natural scenes, with greater chromaticity, as well as a cool light with which to work safely in digitizing or documenting objects sensitive to temperature changes.
