Digitize Vs Model

0
468

Today I started reviewing certain correction proposals for an article about the world of Structure from Motion, which an “expert” had suggested to me for its publication.

The expert’s suggestions were justified as follows:

“Firstly, the title, as it contains a serious error. They call it “Modeling” when in fact it is “Digitization”. Modeling involves creation from measurements of idealized elements using tools such as AutoCAD, 3DStudio, or Blender. By idealized, I mean that an operator introduces the characteristics they observe, measure, or intuit if they do not exist, from the original model. Unlike digitization, modeling does not generate holes, it is visually attractive and produces models with few polygons. Digitization, which is what is done with SfM or scanners, captures reality exactly as it is, with its imperfections, occlusions, and with an aesthetic that, although realism is appreciated, the presence of holes causes some unease in the observer”

This has made me reflect on the use of the term “digitize” to describe processes involving the transition from a physical reality to a digital one, or the use of certain devices for such conversions.

Digitization by definition is an analog-to-digital conversion process, whereby an analog signal, for example an electromagnetic wave, is sampled, quantized, and encoded in digital terms.

For example, when light reaches our sensor in the form of an electromagnetic wave, it is sampled (organized into a grid) by the matrix of our sensor, quantized, insofar as each cell of that grid records more or less energy, and subsequently that signal is encoded digitally to generate a raster image.

But when 3D scanners are used, whether laser or structured light, what we do is numerically describe a surface through a set of “points” inscribed in a coordinate system, generating a mathematical model based on three-dimensional information. SfM performs the same process but from raster images, while a laser scanner does it directly from reality through the delay in an emitted-received pulse, or structured light does it through the deformation of known light patterns.

In summary, digitizing implies an analog-to-digital conversion, and modeling mathematically represents a physical reality; therefore, the act of creating models I think is more correctly called modeling, and the act of converting analog-digital signals digitizing.

Personally, I do consider it “serious” to classify a process as digitization or modeling based on whether it has “holes” or not, or whether it is more or less “realistic”.